Guilty About Reading Genre?

Have you ever felt guilty for reading a cozy, a mystery, or a romantic novel instead of delving into one of the great books, like Homer’s Iliad or Proust’s Swan Way or a classic like Virginia Wolf’s A Room of One’s Own?

I grew up in northern Mexico and I attended a fantastic high school that was accredited in both Mexico and the US, giving students the opportunity to attend the university in either country.

The school offered a two-semester English literature class. The teacher was a dynamic, talented woman who instilled in her students the love for the classics and the great books. She also encouraged us to shun genre and to avoid soap operas, quite popular at the time.

I moved to the US in my mid-twenties and soon discovered romance novels. After devouring a romantic story with a happy ending, I’d run to the library to borrow books by Tolstoy or Dostoyevsky to balance my reading guilt. Compare the fun of reading genre to the lessons of the great books. It’s very different reading! The great books represent the foundations of Western Culture’s ethics, social norms, values, and ideas that stem from the Greco-Roman tradition. Genre, on the other hand, is pure entertainment.

Fast forward a few years when I was working in international finance and traveling the world for my corporate job.

On a flight between New York and Buenos Aires, Argentina, I missed my connection in Miami. I window-shopped airport stores in search of something to do until the next flight. A bookstore, displaying mountains of books set on tables that stretched down the hall, caught my eye.

The year was 2001 – the year I discovered the mystery novel. I purchased Tell No One by Harlan Coben and I was immediately hooked on mysteries. My new-found love in reading would disappoint my wonderful literature teacher back in Mexico, yet for the rest of my international finance career, I carried a mystery or two to read on long flights.

Mysteries became an important part of my life. So important, in fact, that I left the corporate world to write the Nikki Garcia mystery series, setting my stories in a few of those international locations where I traveled. Do I still feel guilty? Not at all!

At a book signing four years ago, I met Harlan Coben. I told him his novels influenced me to write mysteries.

And my former teacher says she loves my novels and she’s thrilled that one of her pupils became a writer. Instead of feeling like a wayward former student, I’ve converted her to reading genre.

***

About Kathryn

Kathryn Lane writes mystery and suspense novels usually set in foreign countries. In her award-winning Nikki Garcia Mystery Series, her protagonist is a private investigator based in Miami. Her latest publication is a coming-of-age novel, Stolen Diary, about a socially awkward math genius.

Kathryn’s early work life started out as a painter in oils. To earn a living, she became a certified public accountant and embarked on a career in international finance with Johnson & Johnson.

Two decades later, she left the corporate world to create mystery and suspense thrillers, drawing inspiration from her travels in over ninety countries as well as her life in Mexico, Australia, Argentina, and the United States.

She also dabbles in poetry, an activity she pursues during snippets of creative renewal. In the summer, Kathryn and her husband, Bob Hurt, escape the Texas heat for the mountains of northern New Mexico.

Stolen Diary

Kindle: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BSHFRD11

Paperback: https://www.amazon.com/Stolen-Diary-Kathryn-Lane/dp/1735463833/

Photo credits:

Girl Reading by Camille Corot, Metropolitan Museum of Art

Harlan Coben and Kathryn Lane by Bob Hurt

15 replies
  1. Mark
    Mark says:

    I don’t feel guilty at all for reading mysteries. I’m not in school, and I read for fun. This is what I find fun. I have a job to make me do things I’d rather not be doing (the adult equivalent of reading the classics.) 🙂

  2. T.K. Thorne
    T.K. Thorne says:

    My Granny frowned on my love of comic books which morphed into science fiction. I still live a good Sifi and the genre has prepared me for living in this fast-changing world.

    • Kathryn Lane
      Kathryn Lane says:

      On occasion when get a message or a reminder or answer a phone call on my iWatch, I remember Dick Tracey’s watch that I was fascinated with when I was a kid. And now we have technology that we became familiar years ago through science fiction! Good science fiction always predicts the future!!

  3. Saralyn
    Saralyn says:

    I’m a former English teacher, and I believe reading the classics is important for many reasons. I’m concerned that many schools have eliminated literature from their curricula. But I also believe that every book has its lessons, and reading mysteries is good for the brain, good for the psyche. Thanks for this interesting post, Kathryn.

  4. Donnell Ann Bell
    Donnell Ann Bell says:

    I’ve read the classics as part of my education. I read various genres for the same reason. A well-written book can educate and entertain. Reading enlightens and kudos to Kathryn’s teacher and Saralyn for being open to such a concept. There are some who aren’t.

  5. Debra H. Goldstein
    Debra H. Goldstein says:

    I love that you balanced classic against romance and mystery. I’ve always felt reading different types of books influences not only writing, but the way brains become wired. Glad you tried all of these things .. and I agree with your teacher, glad you became a writer as I so enjoy your books.

Comments are closed.