BOOK COVERS-Eeeek
BOOK COVERS–WHAT A NIGHTMARE!
When I first started out, back in the dark ages (1980s) before the Internet—heck—before home computers, I was as naïve as a newborn baby. I joined Mystery Writers of America, the chapter that met in Houston, and met some lovely, well-published authors.
I didn’t know squat (except what I’d read in magazines and books I’d purchased). I needed all the encouragement I could get, and I did get it. After a while, I was writing and submitting and, of course, receiving rejections, learning craft (we’re always learning craft, right?) and discovering what’s-what in the traditional book publishing business. There was no real self-publishing then (though there were, as now, vanity publishers), or as we call it now, Independent Publishing.
One of the things I found out from some of these published authors was that the author had no say so over her cover no matter how many books she’d written and published. You took what you got. Oh, the stories I heard. One particularly lovely author of over 140 books, Joan Lowery Nixon (1927-2003), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Lowery_Nixon, who became a pretty good friend, regaled me with stories of her experiences regarding the covers of her books. The story I remember most is when she set a book in pancake-flat Houston, but the cover had mountains in the background. She said she’d had many “discussions” with the publisher before the book came out, to no avail.
My first published book, My First Murder, which St. Martin’s Press, Inc. published, had a colorful cover, which other than there being what one could assume was a dead woman on the cover, had no relation to the story. By that I mean the cover was in the style of Mexican art. (I like Mexican art, don’t get me wrong.) The book was set in Houston and Ft. Worth.
Some years later, my small press publisher contacted me one day and asked me what I wanted on the cover of the book they were putting out. You know, I had never given it any thought, my experience having been that I had no choice. One of my friends said if I was going to come up with a design for a cover, I should be paid. What did I know? I gave the publisher ideas, but by the time I sent in photographs and more information about what I thought, they had taken my original idea and run with it. The cover wasn’t that good. Years later, I’ve been re-publishing some books myself (of course I have my rights back) and am on my fourth cover for my first one.
Anyway, now, years and a number of covers later, as an “Independent” author I have sole control. There are days I wish someone else had the responsibility, so I’d be off the hook. It’s not easy coming up with ideas. I’m a writer, not an artist. I’m about to put out the 6th in my Mavis Davis series and have been racking my brain. The title is The Underground Murders. If any of you have an idea for a cover, without knowing the plot, PLEASE contact me asap.
You may contact the author at Susan@susanpbaker.com.
Susan is the author of fourteen (14) books, mostly mystery/suspense, but not all.
Interesting cover evolution. I feel your pain. I loved the cover a small press used for Maze in Blue, a mystery set on the University of Michigan’s campus in the 1970’s as it had a bleed into one of the campus’s most famous buildings, but the mass market cover was a pinball maze that had nothing to do with the book. When I objected, they added the Wolverine mascot head as the center of the pinball maze.
I feel your pain! Thanks for writing.
Susan, at least your cover didn’t feature a heroine with three arms. That’s what happened to Christina Dodd 30 years ago, but in the ultimate lemons to lemonade, it became the biggest break of her career. https://www.youtube.com/embed/IJOt31_U5wM?rel=0?rel=0&autoplay=1
What a great story. Thanks for sharing it.
I think your cover evolution has resulted in a more modern, eye-catching, relevant, and effective cover. (I liked the first one, too, as a bit of impressionist artwork., and the second as a straight, to-the-point bit of marketing.) I agree with you, though, about cover designing. What one person loves, another abhors, and a third has no opinion. Best of luck with your new cover.
Thank you, my friend. I have an idea but I have to come up with all the little stuff before I can get the designer started. Working on the blurb now. I dream about it!
Susan, your own cover designer exceeds the ex-publisher’s attempts. Good for you! I had a similar experience with my first publisher, who would not budge from the misleading, inappropriate cover for my book. I waited the seven years of that contract to be free to redo that cover and the others that came after.
Eeeek, 7 years? What a horror story! A 7 year contract WHEW. You’re so patient. I bet you wanted to go up there and strangle whoever was responsible!